Some of the charm of the past consists of the quiet—the great distracting buzz of implication has stopped and we are left only with what has been fully phrased and precisely stated. And part of the melancholy of the past comes from our knowledge that the huge, unrecorded hum of implication was once there and left no trace—we feel that because it is evanescent it is especially human.
— Lionel Trilling, The Liberal Imagination (1950)
The most historic election ever. It is a cliché, I know, especially when it is repeated every election cycle. But I think there is a truth hidden in it. Elections are an interruption of the ordinary. Politics normally exists within Trilling’s great distracting buzz of implication. But for a brief moment, when votes are cast and new leaders are selected, the great hum leaves a trace.
The midterms two weeks ago were a historic mark. The Democrats had the strongest showing, for any party, in decades. Next Congress, the Dems will have at least a 255-167 majority in the House and a 55-44 caucus in the Senate, decisively shifting the power of legislative production. Propelled by weariness from high inflation and corruption in the Trump Administration, voters swung, putting Dems in power in both chambers in Congress, four new governorships, and a dozen state legislative chambers.
Data centers (DCs) were seemingly everywhere on the campaign trail. In Texas, Republican Governor Greg Abbott lost to Gina Hinojosa, who made it a central issue of her campaign. In Ohio, Sherrod Brown defeated standing Senator Jon Husted, likely because of his position on data centers. Forty-six different municipalities voted against data centers. “People really effing hate data centers,” Abdul El-Sayed said at a campaign event.
And while data centers were the center of attention for some races, the record was thin on AI policy. Ken Paxton and Josh Hawley stumped on chatbot child safety, while Abdul El-Sayed endorsed an AI policy platform in late July. But those issues didn’t move crowds like data centers. As I explain below, I think the framework of political scientist Douglas Arnold can explain why data centers did so well this cycle and also why the OpenAI–Hugging Face incident earlier this year didn’t convert into tangible legislative text. In the way that the causal chain is strong for data centers, it is weak for broader AI concerns.
Next Congress, I will be following closely to see how this develops and if the Dems are able to connect the dots. A big question for the next Congress is whether or not the energy over data centers will transfer into broader AI concerns. Let’s dive in.